Understanding the Difference Between the FCA and SEC

Wrapped Up:

  • The Financial Conduct Authority is the primary financial regulatory body in the UK, while the Securities and Exchange Commission serves a similar role in the US.
  • The FCA and the SEC share similar goals, aiming to protect investors and ensure the integrity of the financial markets.
  • However, they do adopt unique approaches in terms of regulations, structure, scope, and funding that differentiate the two authorities.


The Two Regulators

The financial services industry is a vital component of modern economies, providing crucial services such as investment banking, asset management, and insurance to both individuals and businesses. Given the complexity and importance of this sector, it is imperative that there exist regulatory bodies to oversee and monitor financial institutions to ensure their compliance with legal and ethical standards. In both the United Kingdom and the United States, two prominent regulatory bodies fulfil this role: the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the US.


What is the Financial Conduct Authority?

The FCA is the regulatory body responsible for overseeing the conduct of financial firms and individuals in the UK. It was established in 2013 and operates independently of the UK government. The FCA’s main objective is to ensure the integrity and stability of the UK financial system, promote healthy competition in financial markets, and protect the interests of consumers. The FCA has broad regulatory powers, including the ability to set and enforce rules for financial institutions, conduct investigations, and levy fines for non-compliance. The FCA also works closely with other regulatory bodies in the UK, such as the Bank of England and the Prudential Regulation Authority, to coordinate regulatory efforts and maintain financial stability.


What is the Securities and Exchange Commission?

In contrast, the SEC is the primary regulatory body overseeing the securities industry in the US. Established in 1934 in response to the Great Depression, the SEC is an independent agency of the US government. The SEC’s mission is to protect investors, maintain fair and efficient markets, and facilitate capital formation. Like the FCA, the SEC has extensive regulatory powers, including the authority to register and regulate securities exchanges, enforce securities laws, and investigate and prosecute securities violations. The SEC also works closely with other federal agencies, such as the Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation, to combat financial crime and maintain market integrity.


Comparing the FCA and SEC

One key difference between the FCA and the SEC is their regulatory approach. The FCA operates under a principles-based regulatory framework, which emphasises the importance of principles such as integrity, transparency, and accountability in guiding the conduct of financial institutions. In contrast, the SEC operates under a rules-based regulatory framework, which relies on a detailed set of rules and regulations to govern the behaviour of financial institutions. While the principles-based approach allows for greater flexibility and adaptability in response to changing market conditions, the rules-based approach provides clarity and certainty for market participants.

Additionally, the SEC and the FCA differ in terms of their organisational structure and funding. The SEC is an independent agency of the U.S. government that is funded by fees and assessments on securities transactions. The FCA, on the other hand, is a regulatory body that is funded by fees and levies on the firms that it regulates. This difference in funding mechanisms can impact the priorities and focus of each regulatory body.

Despite these differences, both the SEC and the FCA share a common goal of protecting investors and ensuring the integrity of the financial markets. They both play a critical role in maintaining confidence in the financial system and preventing fraud and misconduct. By working together and sharing best practices, the SEC and the FCA can continue to strengthen their regulatory frameworks and uphold the highest standards of professionalism and integrity in the financial industry.

Another difference between the FCA and the SEC is their scope of regulation. The FCA has a broader mandate to regulate all financial firms and individuals in the UK, including banks, insurance companies, and investment managers. In contrast, the SEC focuses specifically on regulating the securities industry in the US, including securities exchanges, broker-dealers, and investment advisers. While the FCA’s broader scope allows for comprehensive oversight of the entire financial services industry, the SEC’s narrower focus enables it to develop specialised expertise in regulating securities markets.

To summarise, the FCA in the UK and the SEC in the US play vital roles in regulating the financial services industry in their respective countries. While both regulatory bodies share similar objectives of maintaining market integrity and protecting investors, they differ in their regulatory approach, scope of regulation, and organisational structure. By understanding the differences between the FCA and the SEC, market participants may gain valuable insights into the regulatory landscape and navigate the complex world of financial regulation more effectively.



These are the views of the Author only. It is not Investment Advice or a Recommendation from Gather International Limited or its affiliates.

Capital at risk. Always do your own due diligence and consult with a qualified financial professional before making any investment decisions.

This article is for informational and educational purposes only.